Yesterday we had dinner over at the new place my folks are staying. As detailed before, my folks aren't in the best of condition. Father's doing great for a guy of 90 - mobile and interested in the things around him - but Mother's in hospice care, and we're surprised she's lasted as long as she has.
But she doesn't get out much, in fact, she doesn't even get out of bed or sit up. Father takes care of her quite a bit, and the folks at the assisted living facility are diligent in their care of her - making sure she's clean and turning her from side to side. Mother doesn't talk much any more, and she's almost blind... so we've taken to taking dinners over there. Thankgiving dinner worked nicely with food from Boston Market, Christmas dinner also worked well using the normal foods.
Yesterday, Father had steak. A BIG steak, and he put down about 3/4ths of it. Mother had a little bit - but not much. And yesterday we dragged out some old mess hall trays to eat on - we've had those for 15 years or more, They're this style, though with no discernable markings so it's hard to tell just how old they are.
We've had them stored under the stove - so you can imagine how great they looked. For some reason there was this brownish tarnish on them, that was resistant to pretty much everything I had on hand. (I was tempted to use 400 grit sandpaper, but refrained.) The harshest scouring powder I had and used was "Bon Ami" - and it didn't cut the tarnish at all. (I was tempted to use Comet, but thought that was a bit much.) I washed them enough so they were clean - but they didn't look good at all. They were, however, 'clean enough to eat off of.', so we did.
These work pretty well - there's a signficant shortage of counter and table space in my folk's room, and these worked better than plates and bowls would have. We cooked the food here at home, plated it out there, and had a pretty good time. Give the trays a cursory wipe to clean off the big gunk, and stack them for cleaning later.
(And I was determined to clean them!)
So now, I needed to find something that'd cut that tarnish and clean the one that'd gotten 'rusty'. Well, it looked like rust, flaked like rust - that's close enough to rust for me...
The local grocery provided steel wool pads (a last resort thing), Scotchbrite pads, Cameo cleanser and a product I'd used before with good effect - "Barkeeper's Friend". I figured, what the heck - let's do a product comparison.
The trays were cleaned slightly with warm water and detergent to get the food residues off. Then I tried the next harshest stuff - the Cameo cleanser with a soft pad.
It didn't work. I tried it with a Scotchbrite pad and it worked a bit - but I think it was more the pad than the cleaner.
Then it was time for the Barkeeper's Friend. A soft pad with the stuff worked a bit better than the Cameo - but when I used the Scotchbrite I really started cutting the tarnish. I let the stuff sit for a few minutes, stacking the trays in the sink with a thin layer of the stuff between them, and then took the Scotchbrite to them, and the tarnish came off pretty easily.
The trays are looking a LOT better, to the point where the things look almost new - at least from the front. The backs still need some work, but not all that much now.
We'll keep using the trays for the dinners over at my folks. Now they're clean and shiny they'll see a lot more use!
And Father? He laughed at them - said they reminded him of his time in the Navy in WW2. Heck, for all I know, they're that old!
So to recap on the cleaning materials...
Bon Ami and a soft pad are fine for light stuff, won't touch the heavy. Won't scratch.
Cameo? Eh. About as effective as Bon Ami.
Scotchbrite pad? Effective at getting stuff off - works best with lots of elbow grease. May scratch softer materials.
Bar Keeper's Friend? This stuff will cut through the most stubborn stains, and will scratch shiny materials if used carelessly. I don't know what the abrasive is, but it'll do the job - if you aren't looking to leave a mirror finish afterward. (And you might even be able to do that with this stuff - with a soft pad and a LOT of elbow grease!)
Well, it was more of a curiosity thing than anything else - what worked best to clean years of tarnish?
Now you know!
J.